Tier 1 - WE DID IT!

What exactly has Tier 1 done? (see email from Tier 1 below)

Currently the first round of sub area plans for the SA Tomorrow planning process are taking place to assist in planning for the future with 1 million more people. Despite this, they’ve kept their 20-30 year old neighborhood plans alive (Monte Vista’s plan is 30 years old!). Plans that have very general land use plans that do not correlate with any zoning policy, and do not connect land use to transit, walkability, or neighborhood connectivity. They kept alive neighborhood plans that work in isolation from each other – there isn’t any comprehensiveness about the plans. Most of the plans call for the downzone of duplexes, triplexes and quadplexes back to single family residences – so tier 1 is cheering to keep exclusionary zoning practices alive. Many of the plans get way off topic of issues related to planning…i.e. discussing policies on stray dogs and park programming, these are not appropriate for community plans. None of the neighborhood plans are aware of the reality of population growth or aware of the market forces at play with development of the city.

SANE is not sure why they are celebrating. These neighborhood plans should be washed away with new plans that consider population growth, land use connection to transit and walkability, housing affordability, integration of diverse groups of people in all neighborhoods, diverse housing choices, and promotion of inclusionary land use and zoning practices from the 21st Century.

--------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Cynthia Spielman <cspielmanbhana@gmail.com>
Date: Thu, May 17, 2018, 2:40 AM
Subject: WE DID IT!
To: Tier One Neighborhood Coalition <t1nc.sat@gmail.com>


We’ve done it together!

 Because of our voices that insisted on the inclusion of our neighborhood plans into the SA Tomorrow Comprehensive Plan it has happened. After all of our hard work and commitment, our plans will be intact as promised. This is a moment to be proud of! Congratulations Tier One Neighborhoods for speaking out!

Councilman Roberto Trevino deserves our thanks in insisting that our voices be heard by the City and that our neighborhoods be protected.  Please send him a thanks and perhaps copy your own councilperson. I am attaching the addresses below. 

It is important to remember that this "change" in process is really only a reflection of promises that were made all along to neighborhoods and all that neighborhoods were asking for - respect for the work that was done on the neighborhood plans by residents of those neighborhoods and consistent with the language in the original ordinances that neighborhood plans would be periodically reviewed and updated. 

This change will actually improve the process of the sub-area planning as most of the neighborhood plans already provide the information that the Planning Dept has said it is seeking through the planning process while greatly improving the relationship between neighborhoods and the Planning Dept.

We would encourage neighborhoods to prepare for their role now that they are being given the opportunity to review and update their plans. We’ve attached some suggestions on how neighborhoods can best prepare. 

Congratulations Tier One!


Roberto.Trevino@sanantonio.gov,      Council.District1@sanantonio.gov,

cruz.shaw@sanantonio.gov,      Council.District2@sanantonio.gov,

rebecca.viagran@sanantonio.gov,     Council.District3@sanantonio.gov,

Rey.Saldana@sanantonio.gov,           Council.District4@sanantonio.gov,

Shirley.Gonzales@sanantonio.gov,    Council.District5@sanantonio.gov,

Greg.Brockhouse@sanantonio.gov,   Council.District6@sanantonio.gov,

Ana.Sandoval@sanantonio.gov,         Council.District7@sanantonio.gov,

Manny.Pelaez@sanantonio.gov,        Council.District8@sanantonio.gov,

 John.Courage@sanantonio.gov,        Council.District9@sanantonio.gov,

Clayton.Perry@sanantonio.gov,         Council.District10@sanantonio.gov


Ron.Nirenberg@sanantonio.gov,       Mayor.ronnirenberg@sanantonio.gov